Before the All-Star break, many thought Aaron Judge would coast to MVP and Rookie of the Year trophies. He broke Joe DiMaggio’s rookie home run record in just 82 days. He won the All-Star Home Run Derby. But then the All-Star break came and went. Now As of August 12th, Judge has a .182 average with only five home runs since the break. At this point it’s difficult to name him the Rookie of the Year. That’s why the powers that be should name Andrew Benintendi the American League Rookie of the Year.
Benintendi has maintained his pace of play all season and is only getting better. He blasted two home runs against the New York Yankees on August 12th. He also hit two home runs against the Texas Rangers on July 4th in a 5-for-5 day at the plate with with 6 RBI and double. That game ended in a 11-4 victory for the Red Sox. These numbers, while not as strong as Judge’s, still support the argument that he should be the Rookie of the Year.
Name Andrew Benintendi Alongside Fred Lynn As Two Rookie Greats
It’s hard for any die-hard Red Sox fan not to think of Fred Lynn when they watch Benintendi. Lynn had a MVP and Rookie of the Year-winning season in 1975 that also included a Gold Glove and All-Star appearance. Not to mention the Red Sox went onto the World Series that year.
But here’s why they should name Andrew Benintendi the Rookie of the Year. He’s maintained a consistent pace this year and it’s helped keep the Red Sox in first place. There isn’t much of a correlation between Aaron Judge’s hitting and the Yankees place in the AL East. The Yankees fell out of first long before Judge’s slump. But there’s been much more consistency with Benintendi. He’s also an amazing outfielder and base runner.
Judge isn’t going to recover from his slump anytime soon. Not to mention it would be very awkward if Judge for the RoY award after such a poor post-All-Star break. So name Andrew Benintendi the Rookie of the Year as he is the more deserving player.