The Red Sox Need A Consistent Lineup

Minutes after I finished musing about manager John Farrell’s strengths, I realized that the Red Sox lineup is very inconsistent. One minute I look up and Dustin Pedroia is hitting sixth. Then I look up again and he’s leading off.

red sox lineup

Likewise, I feel like I’ve seen a different outfield combination every night. Granted there’s been a lot of injuries, but it’s still not helping the team’s lack of hitting. There needs to be a change. One of the reasons why the Red Sox lineup succeeded so much in 2016 is because it was consistent. Sure, you had a platoon in left field and an occasional off day, but it was predictable. Now, I look up and I see seemingly a different catcher and third baseman every night. Not to mention left field/center field.

For a team that is already missing the offensive production of David Ortiz, a solid and cohesive lineup is essential for success. Let alone the impact on defense. Here are my suggestions.

Red Sox Lineup Suggestions

  1. Keep Pedroia and Betts near the top of the lineup. Preferably leadoff and third respectively.
  2. Continue to bat Benintendi second, as he seems to be handling the pressure well, batting .327.
  3. Hanley stays in the clean-up spot. The guy hits bombs and is the only real power threat on the team other than maybe Betts.
  4. Put Mitch Moreland fifth because he can slap the ball the other way to drive in runs.
  5. Bogaerts needs to stay in the six hole, even though he’s one of the best hitters on the team. I think it suits him well to hit after Moreland matchup wise as well as RBI wise.
  6. Whether the third baseman is Sandoval, Hernandez, Holt, or whoever, they should bat seventh, again mainly based on match-ups.
  7. Jackie Bradley, who’s been struggling offensively this year, should bat eighth unless Leon is catching, then Bradley should bat ninth.
  8. Should Vazquez be catching, he should bat ninth.