Benintendi Promotion To Majors Should Wait

If you’re like me, then you’re tracking Andrew Benintendi’s progress through the Red Sox farm system. The Red Sox announced the Benintendi promotion within hours after a tense but anti-climactic trade deadline. Many fans rejoiced at this move, especially since Benintendi plays left field. If Benintendi can fill that void in left field, which hasn’t been consistently patrolled by anyone lately, he could earn a permanent spot on the roster. Despite Benintendi’s success in the minors, his true test is yet to come. Personally, I think it’s too soon for a Benintendi promotion. Here me out.

One could argue that Benintendi has to get his feet wet in the majors at some point. IBenintendi promotion don’t disagree. But bypassing him from Portland straight to the Red Sox this fast? Most players have a hard enough time coming up from Pawtucket. Why would Beintendi be any different?

Let’s look at some of our current stars who stumbled during their first few years. Jackie Bradley Jr. is now an All-Star centerfielder. He has a cannon for an arm, and he’s finally posting a strong batting average. But in 2014, Bradley Jr. posted a .198 batting average in 384 at-bats. That average came a year after he hit .275 in AAA Pawtucket. Mookie Betts didn’t have a bad rookie year. He hit .291 in 189 at-bats. But he hit .335 in Pawtucket in almost the same amount of at-bats that same year. That’s a 44 point drop. Benintendi’s stats show he has a hard time adjusting after a promotion.

The other reason I believe Benintendi is too young is that Major League pitchers and coaches have probably had a chance to study him for a while now. Benintendi, however, probably hasn’t had that same chance given his soon he’s been called up. Is he prepared? In A+ Salem this year, Benintendi hit .341 in 135 at-bats. His average dropped 46 points to .291 when he moved up to Double-A Portland. Seeing a drop in one’s batting average after a promotion is to be expected. But 46 points? That’s hard to ignore.

Benintendi Promotion Doesn’t Consider Dimensions of Fenway Park.

My final concern about Benintendi is that he’s a lefty. He’s only 5’10 and 170 lbs. He’s not strong enough yet to hit home runs (He looks so small in a batting helmet too). Why is this a bad thing? While he’s his twelve triples in the minors this season, as a lefty, those triples are going to turn into flyouts in Fenway Park. The right field line in Single-A Salem Red Sox Memorial Baseball Stadium is 325 feet long. The right field line in Double-A Portland’s Hadlock Field is 330. The right field line in Fenway Park might only be 302 feet, but deep right field is 380 feet. That difference of 78 feet between right and deep right is more than enough room for opposing outfielders to snag Benintendi’s line drives.

Some say that Dombrowski is promoting Benintenid to fill a void in left field because of all the injuries to this season’s left fielders. But Fenway Park doesn’t have just any left field. It has the Green Monster. Anyone who has played left field at Fenway will tell you it’s a difficult wall to patrol. You never know how far a ball will bounce, or if it’ll just drop like a rock. I’m willing to bet that Benintendi has NO experience playing a left field wall like that.

This Andrew Benintendi promotion is premature. Given him a few more months in Double-A before moving him up to Pawtucket. By the time he’s had some at-bats in AAA, he should be prepared to make his debut with the Boston Red Sox.

Red Sox Promote Andrew Benintendi

Overnight, the Red Sox promoted prized prospect Andrew Benintendi to the Major Leagues, adding to the trade deadline intrigue. Evan Drellich of the Boston Herald broke the news, and Michael Martinez was designated for assignment to make way for Benintendi. The outfielder will join the team in Seattle on Tuesday.

Who is Andrew Benintendi?

Andrew Benintendi

Benintendi was a first round pick in the 2015 draft, and his rise has been meteoric. He reached Single-A in his first professional season, and has dominated this year, too. A .312/.378/.532 slash line at High-A Salem earned Benintendi a promotion to Double-A Portland. In 63 games with the Sea Dogs, he slashed .295/.357/.515 with 8 home runs and 44 RBI. That piqued the attention of Dave Dombrowski, who will slot the 22-year old in left field amid a heated pennant race.

Andrew Benintendi is the Red Sox’ number two prospect, behind Yoan Moncada. A lefty hitter, he is above average in every facet of the game, with obvious upside offensively. His promotion should provide a jolt of energy to the Red Sox, with Brock Holt likely sliding back into a utility role.

The Risk of Skipping Triple-A

Even though Benintendi is very highly rated, this is a risky move. The guy has still only played 151 professional baseball games. None of them were above Double-A. By all account, his makeup and ability should enable a smooth transition, but skipping an entire level of minor league development is rarely advisable. Whether people like it or not, Andrew Benintendi will still have plenty to learn. The Red Sox just figure that process should happen at the Major League level.

Benintendi is likely to be in uniform tonight against the Mariners. His debut will come Wednesday, as the youngster is given time to settle. Andrew is likely to see plenty of playing time against right-handed pitching, with further opportunities arising based on his performance. He will join other young stars like Mookie Betts and Xander Bogaerts to create a great core for the Red Sox.

“Our people kept coming up and saying, ‘We think he can play at the big league level,'” said Dombrowski. “Don’t look for him to hit in the middle of the lineup like he will eventually, but he’s a well-rounded player, he’s a good defensive player, and he runs the bases well. He has a good arm, we’ve been working him out at left field and he’s been able to play the wall well in Portland there.”

It will be fun to see how this plays out. Every young player is likely to struggle at some point, especially after jumping two whole levels in a system. But the future face of your Boston Red Sox has arrived. Andrew Benintendi has reached the Majors. It’s time to get excited.

Will the Red Sox Acquire Anyone Today?

We are in the final hours of Major League Baseball’s trade deadline. Will the Boston Red Sox acquire anyone before 4pm? It’s not looking like Dave Dombrowski will make any deals today, at least not yet. But with names like Andrew Benintendi and Christian Vazquez coming up as players the Red Sox might trade, it’s hard to say. Other prospects like Yoan Moncada, Michael Kopech, and Rafael Davers are also trending on Twitter in relation to possible trades. With players like Chris Sale, Carlos Beltran, and Jonathan Lucroy up for grabs, anything is possible!

To see Benintendi traded, one of Boston’s top prospects, would shock the Red Sox Nation, especiallyRed sox acquire when many believe Benintendi is an untouchable prospect. After all, he has an amazing history. Initially drafted by the Cincinatti Reds in the 31st round of the 2013 MLB draft, Benintendi instead enrolled at the University of Arkansas. In 2015, Benentendi led the Southeastern Conference with a .380 batting average and 19 home runs before being named the SEC Player of the Year and winning the Baseball America College Player of the Year Award. He was drafted again in 2015, this time by the Boston Red Sox as a seventh overall draft pick with a $3.6 million bonus. Benintendi debuted with the Lowell Spinners in the Class-A New York-Penn League later that year.

Some believe Andrew Benintendi could be the next Carl Yastrzemski. He’s currently hitting over .300 between stints at Single and Double-A levels. His twelve triples alone signify his developing strength and speed. Between his power, speed, and eye coordination, the Red Sox can’t let an offensive and defensive asset slip away. It’s a little harder to say the same about Christian Vazquez. Vazquez is a good defensive player. But he’s an offensive dud.

If Red Sox Acquire Sale, It Shouldn’t Be For Benentendi, Moncada, or Kopech.

Personally, I think it would be a bad idea to let Andrew Benintendi go. Benintendi’s strengths and potential outweigh any reason to trade him. And as I’ve said before, I strongly doubt that Chris Sale is worth trading Benintendi for. He’s an excellent pitcher, but  he’s totally unstable. Our pitchers need run support, not an addition. The Red Sox currently lead the American League in runners left on base. Instead of worrying about pitching, we should focus on clutch hitting. So with that said, it might make more sense if the Red Sox acquire Lucroy or Beltran. Beltran is a .300 hitter with runners on base, and runners in scoring position. So get them for Vazquez or Blake Swiart (and throw Clay Buchholz in too). We don’t need pitching. We need clutch hitters.

Top Prospects Must Stay With Red Sox

As the trade deadline approaches, talks loom about who the Red Sox will let go in exchange for a strong pitcher. The most recent news points to the White Sox scouting players like Yoan Moncada and Andrew Benintendi. According to ESPN, the White Sox sent scouts to watch Boston’s Double-A team on July 28th. Moncada and Benintendi play there now. Personally, I don’t think any pitcher in the MLB is quite worth giving up Moncada or Benintendi, especially Chris Sale. If Boston wants to make it to another World Series, then the Red Sox top prospects must stay in the farm system.

Yoan Moncada has already stolen 43 bases in stints at Single and Double-A this season.Red Sox Top Prospects Must Stay He’ll easily be a .300 average hitter in time. He can also hit for power. The fact that he can play infield, and serve as a designed hitter only adds to his value.

Andrew Benintendi is the next Carl Yastrzemski. He’s currently hitting over .300 with twelve triples between stints at Single and Double-A levels. You can attribute his triples to his developing strength and speed. Overall, he’s developing power, speed, and eye coordination, which will be both offensive and defensive assets. These factors signal that he’ll become a Boston superstar.

Let’s not forget about Michael Kopech. The guy is a wizard on the mound. Anyone his age that can throw 105 MPH is definitely worth keeping around. He pitched a immaculate inning a few weeks ago. He’s currently carrying an ERA of 1.35 in 26 innings this season. While that’s not a lot to bank on right now, it’s a VERY promising sign of what’s to come.

Experts like famed sportswriter Peter Gammons claim that all three of these prospects are “untouchable” and can’t be traded. According to ESPN, however, Dave Dombrowski said last week that “teams’ motivations tend to change as the deadline creeps closer.” Let’s hope that Gammons is right on this one.

Red Sox Top Prospects Must Stay To Create A New Dynasty

Seeing all three of these prospects on the field in Fenway Park in the near future would be riveting. They’ll be a throwback to the days of Yaz, Boggs, and Clemens. Players like Jackie Bradley Jr., Mookie Betts, Steven Wright, and Xander Bogaerts will be veterans by then. They can guide Moncada, Benintendi, and Kopech towards a dynasty that Boston hasn’t seen the likes of since the turn of the 20th century when the Red Sox won five World Series between 1903 and 1918. Moncada, Benintendi, Kopech, and other Red Sox top prospects must stay with the team if this dynasty is ever going to come to fruition.

Mookie Betts Leave Boston for Chris Sale?

The trade deadline is quickly approaching. Dave Dombrowski is vague about who he might buy. He’s being even more quiet about who will leave. One name that comes up is Mookie Betts. Would Mookie Betts leave Boston? Would Dave Dombrowski actually let go of one of our very best in exchange for a pitcher who has wardrobe issues?

MLB.com reported this morning that “[White Sox] could land Mookie Betts and a couple ofMookie Betts Leave Boston top prospects from the group of Andrew Benintendi, Michael Kopech and Yoan Moncada as a starting point for Sale in a hypothetical deal with Boston.”

No. Just No.

There’s no doubt that Chris Sale is a great pitcher. He’s 14-3 with a 3.18 so far this season. But he’s irrational! He’s a loose cannon! He instigated a brawl against Kansas City last season and received a 5 game suspension. At the beginning of this season Sale inserted himself into an issue between Adam LaRoche and the White Sox front office over the presence of LaRoche’s son in the clubhouse. I’m not saying that LaRoche didn’t have a legitimate gripe about the issue, but in my opinion Sale saw an opportunity for self-promotion. It was his chance to stick it to the front office over past issues. I’ll admit that idea is only my own opinion, but the fact is that Sale likes to create drama.

Then there’s the uniform issue. On July 23rd Sale cut up the throwback uniforms that players were supposed to wear for a game that night. Sale was scratched from the lineup, and received a five game suspension as a result of his erratic behavior. Let me repeat that. Sale threw a fit over a uniform. It’s no different from a five year old throwing a tantrum over having to wear a bowtie to church on Sunday. On top of that, if Sale ever cut up the Red Sox 1975 throwback uniforms he’d better hope the Boston police find him before the angry mob does. If Sale knows anything about history, he knows that Bostonians don’t take well to outsiders slamming their heritage.

Do we really want to trade Mookie Betts, along with Andrew Benintendi, Michael Kopech and Yoan Moncada for this guy? We already had a eccentric pitcher like Sale and his name was Bill Lee. But unlike Sale, Lee acted out because of social injustice, and unfair treatment of other players without inserting his own selfish motives. In other words, while Lee himself was a character, he cared an awful lot for his team and teammates, whereas Sale is much more self-serving.

Seeing Mookie Betts Leave Boston Would Be Disastrous

Betts is currently hitting .305 with 20 home runs and 64 RBIs. He OWNS right field, and works well with Jackie Bradley Jr. He’s an offensive and defensive weapon, he’s beloved in Boston, and came up through the Red Sox farm system. And what about Andrew Benintendi, Michael Kopech and Yoan Moncada? Benintendi could be the next Ortiz, Kopech throws faster than anyone else in baseball, and Moncada could be a potential Gold Glove winner when he makes it to the show. Do the Red Sox honestly want to trade these guys away for a loose cannon? To see Mookie Betts leave Boston for a self-serving pitcher would be a disaster, especially since the team already has issues with its current pitching staff.

Betts needs to stay. Sale needs to go elsewhere or stay in Chicago. I don’t care. Just as long as he doesn’t come to Boston.

Michael Kopech Throws Immaculate Inning

Boston Red Sox prospect Michael Kopech recently flashed the greatness that made him a #1 draft pick in 2014. People watch with curiosity and awe when Kopech throws. During a July 7th game against the Carolina Mudcats, Kopech struck out six in four innings. He also only gave up one hit. What was particularly impressive was how he threw an immaculate inning in the fourth. Such an accomplishment is no small task at all.

An immaculate inning in baseball is when the pitcher retires the side on nine pitches. That’sKopech throws three strikes per batter for three outs. Only 75 pitchers in Major League Baseball history have ever thrown an immaculate inning. Out of those 75, only three were rookies. In fact, none in Major League Baseball were thrown between 1929 and 1952. Clay Buchholz and Pedro Martinez are the only two Red Sox pitchers to have accomplished the feat in team history. So seeing Kopech throw an immaculate inning this soon in his career is immaculate in itself. What is perhaps just as impressive is that several of Kopech’s pitches topped 100 MPH, including a 103 MPH fastball in the fourth inning. When someone like Kopech throws 103 MPH, it’s not going to be taken lightly.

Kopeck has not played without controversy. He received a 50-game season-ending suspension last summer for testing positive for the performance-enhancing drug Oxilofreine. Kopech broke his right hand in a fistfight with his roommate the following year, further delaying his return to baseball. So despite his brilliance on the mound, Kopeck still has a ways to go before he can reach the majors.

Major League Baseball currently ranks Kopech the fifth-best prospect in the Red Sox organization behind Yoan Moncada and Andrew Benintendi. Baseball Prospectus ranks him 98th overall. His high ranking is partly why the Red Sox continue to support him. Kopech himself is thankful. “I don’t want to be portrayed as a bad person by any means,” Kopech said in a June 16th Boston.com article. “I mean, the past is the past and I’m ready to just better myself.”