Is Dustin Pedroia Hall of Fame Worthy?

Dustin Pedroia’s career officially came to an end the other day as the Red Sox honored the long time second basemen with a star-studded ceremony on Friday night. Pedroia played 14 seasons, all with Boston from 2006 to 2019. His 2007 season ended up being his official rookie season as he did not log enough at-bats in 2006. He immediately made an impact though in the hearts and minds of Red Sox fans. Despite his small stature his play was large game in and game out. Dustin showed his heart everyday and made sure to leave it all on the field, eventually earning the nickname “Laser Show” for how hard he could hit the ball to all-fields. He put on a show each and every game. He truly gave the team everything he had, until a nagging left knee injury took its toll and he had to call it quits before his time. However, it was still worthy of the Hall of Fame.

STATS

Dustin Pedroia hall

Number 15 was a force at the dish despite his size. Ending his career with 1,805 hits, while clubbing a .299 average for his career. That’s a 162-game average of 193 hits, including reaching 200 hits in a season twice (2008, 2016). With a high rate of reaching base also comes a high rate of scoring, and the Sox looked to their star infielder for that as well. He averaged over a 162-game season; 99 runs scored for a total 922 runs. Scoring 100 runs in a season puts a player in the upper echelon of run scorers and Pedroia averaged that for his career. As expected, he wasn’t the biggest power guy. He hit a modest 140 homeruns, but most second basemen aren’t who you’re looking to for some instant offense. No, Pedroia contributed heavily with the stick by coming through with guys on base. He finished with 725 career Runs Batted In (RBIs) averaging 78 over a 162-game season. Dustin often batted at the top on the lineup, either leadoff or batting second. These are the guys you look to score the runs, not necessarily who you expect to rack up a lot of RBIs. More than enough from a guy at the top of the lineup.

Hall of Fame WAR

Now, all those stats are nice, and are the usual stats everyone sees, but a big stat people look at in determining if a player is Hall of Fame worthy is Wins Above Replacement (WAR). The average career WAR for a Hall of Fame player is about 70 for a career. Pedroia ended with a career WAR of 51.9 according to Baseball Reference. However, 70 is about average for the entire HoF, second basemen historically never had that high of a WAR stat. The highest ever for a second basemen was 127.5 set by Rogers Hornsby. However, Red Sox second basemen Bobby Doerr made the Hall with a 51.1 WAR. New York Yankee Tony Lazzeri made it was a WAR of 47.3. Bill Mazeroski of the Pirates made it with a WAR of 36.5. Pedroia has more than enough WAR as a second basemen to make the hall.

Awards and Accolades

Pedroia also has his fair share of accolades to possibly push him over the edge. He won four Gold Gloves at second (2008, 2011, 2013, and 2014). He was the Rookie of the Year in 2007. He was an all-star four times (2008-10, 2013). A three-time World Series winner (2007, 2013, 2018). Won a silver slugger in 2008. Pedroia also won the American League MVP in 2008 with two more top ten finishes in 2011 and 2013. Dustin Pedroia, to me, is a Hall of Fame Player, and should have his number retired.

Top 5 Dustin Pedroia Moments

For the first time since announcing his retirement, former Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia will make his return to Fenway Park. Earlier this month, Boston announced that June 25th would be “Dustin Pedroia Day” where the team will honor the player who spent his entire 17-year career in Boston. A four-time All-Star and Gold-Glove recipient, Pedroia was one of the best players in all of baseball early in his career. An integral piece in the 2007 and 2013 World Series teams, Pedroia was a three-time champion in Boston. In honor of his great career, we look back at the top five career Dustin Pedroia moments.

5. Saving Clay Buchholz’ no-hitter

It would not be a true Dustin Pedroia list without mentioning his great defense. While it’s tough to pin-point his greatest play, his play in 2007 may be his biggest. Pitcher Clay Buchholz entered the seventh inning having thrown six no-hit innings against the Baltimore Orioles. Baltimore’s Miguel Tejada lead off the inning with a hard grounder back up the middle past Buchholz. Pedroia made an excellent dive at the ball behind second base and quickly got up to just throw out Tejada at first. That play kept the no-hitter intact and allowed Buchholz to go the distance.

4. 25-game hit streak

After missing half of 2010 due to injury, Pedroia had a great bounce back season in 2011. Hitting .307 as well as 21 home runs, he went on a 25-game hit streak from June into July, setting a career-high and the record for Red Sox second basemen. During the streak, Pedroia hit .404 with nine double and nine home runs.

3. The Laser Show Game

With 162 games every season, it’s tough to pick a baseball player’s greatest game. For Pedroia, every Sox fan can pick out what may be his greatest career game. In 2010, he put had the quintessential “Laser Show” against the Colorado Rockies. In a 13-11 extra-innings win, Pedroia went 5 for 5 with three home runs, reaching base six times, and totaling 15 bases. His final home run came in the 10th inning with a man on that put the Red Sox ahead for good. Pedroia would tally five games with five hits in his career, most in Red Sox history.

2. 2007 World Series

Always a team-first player, Pedroia would put his World Series titles above any individual accomplishment. After getting 10 hits in the ALCS, Pedroia became the first rookie ever to lead off a World Series with a home run, putting one over the monster against Colorado’s Jeff Francis. Pedroia played in all 14 of Boston’s postseason games in 2007, hitting .283 across three series.

1. Winning 2008 MVP

After winning Rookie of the Year in 2007, Pedroia went on an absolute tear in 2008. Becoming the eighth player in American League history to win MVP, Gold Glove, and Silver Slugger in the same season, he did it all for the Red Sox. He led the league in runs (118), hits (213) and doubles (54) while hitting .326 and slugging 17 home runs. With the MVP award, Pedroia became the third player all-time to win Rookie of the Year and MVP in consecutive seasons.

West Coast Trip Continues Against The Rockies

After taking on the San Diego Padres, the Red Sox continue their West Coast trip in Denver. Unlike in the past, the Red Sox did well this Player’s Weekend, taking 2 of the 3 games from San Diego. Game one was a 11-0 slug fest for Boston, and game 2 saw the Red Sox win 5-4. Sunday’s game, however, ended in a 3-1 loss to the NL East Padres.

They now look to take on the Colorado Rockies in the second part of the west coast trip.West Coast Trip After splitting the two games in Boston back in May, the Red Sox look to take both games in Denver against the Rockies. Prior to welcoming Boston, the Rockies hosted the Atlanta Braves, and won on a walk off. Ryan McMahon hit a 2 run home run in the bottom of the 9th to win it, 3-1. The game was a make up game from earlier in the season.

Players Weekend in San Diego

After a walk off win in the suspended game on Thursday, the Red Sox traveled to San Diego to face the Padres at Petco Park. Eduardo Rodriguez pitched 7 solid innings, allowing only 5 hits, and striking out 6 batters. JD Martinez hit 2 home runs to propel the Red Sox to the 11-0 win over the struggling Padres.

Game 2 was a bit of a challenge for Boston, as the squeezed out a 5-4 win on Saturday. Nathan Eovaldi made the start for Boston, but only lasted 3 innings, allowing two runs off of 4 hits. Matt Barnes picked up the win, and Brandon Workman earned his 8th save of the season. The game was tied 4-4 until Brock Holt’s 3rd home run of the season in the top of the 9th off of Kirby Yates.

The Red Sox were looking for the sweep in game 3. The Padres had other plans. Brian Johnson was the starter, and only pitched 3 innings until turning it over to the bullpen. Manny Machado hit a 2 run home run in the first off of Johnson, and Francisco Mejia hit a run scoring single for the Padres. JD Martinez hit his 31st home run in the fourth, but the offense fell short, as the Red Sox lost 3-1.

Continuing the West Coast Trip in Denver

After splitting the series in Boston 1-1 back in May, the Red Sox look to take both games in Denver. Rick Porcello will be the game one starter in the west coast trip, and Eduardo Rodriguez will be the game two starter. The Rockes haven’t named a game one starter, but Peter Lambert will be going in game two of the series.

The last time the Red Sox faced the Rockies at Coors Field was in September 2013. That west coast trip saw the Red Sox split the series 1-1. For Alex Cora, coming back to Coors Field will bring back some good memories, as he was part of the 2007 World Series team that beat the Rockies 4-0.

It was reported that fellow 2007 World Series Champion, Dustin Pedroia, will join the team in Denver. The last time Red Sox Nation heard from Pedroia was back in May, when he announced that he was taking a leave from baseball. Pedroia has been in touch with Alex Cora and other members of the Red Sox. It’s reported that he has about two more weeks on crutches, as he underwent another surgery not too long ago.

Closing out the Trip in Anaheim

The Red Sox will close out the West Coast trip in Anaheim against the LA Angels. The last time the Red Sox faced the Angels was at Fenway Park in the beginning of August. The four game set was split 2-2, but the Red Sox are looking to take all three games.

Defying the Odds – The Tale of Dustin Pedroia

From the moment he became a major league baseball player, Dustin Pedroia has been defying the odds. Many called him a bust. Many believed that due to his size, he could never cut it in the big leagues. Here we are fourteen years later. The long time second baseman for the Red Sox is taking a leave from the team. It was announced on Monday that Pedroia is going to take some time to figure things out.

Now, what does that mean? Have we seen the last of the Lasershow? Many fans believedefying the odds that he’s about to hang up his spikes and call it a career. Others think differently. It’s a tough situation for Pedroia, who has been the heart and soul of this team from the very beginning.

Defying the Odds Since Day One

Like many members of Red Sox Nation, we take notice when a new player gets called up to the big leagues. August 22nd 2006 was no different. Fans were wondering who this rookie infielder from Woodland, California was. All that they knew about him was that he was doing well enough in Pawtucket to get the call every player looks to get.

Pedroia isn’t your average infielder, but he won the heart of the Nation. He was a dirt dog on the field. Many dismissed him due to his size, but he made them think twice when he was at second base. From his sweet swing, to the flash of leather, Pedroia is the definition of dirt dog. There was something special about that kid from California. Since 2006, Red Sox Nation got to witness Dustin Pedroia’s career.

Pedroia never gave up the fight to be the best. From winning Rookie of the Year in 2007, to MVP in 2008, he was a complete player. A definite force in the clubhouse, Pedroia led the Red Sox to three World Series Championships. This last one, despite not being able to play, he was able to use his voice and lead. That is the reason why he is “Captain” material, and why he is respected in the clubhouse in Boston.

A Proven Leader In Boston

As mentioned, Pedroia is no doubt the heart and soul of the Red Sox. He has been part of this team for fourteen seasons. This also makes him the ultimate veteran player on the roster. Pedroia is one of the few that can say that they have been with the same organization throughout there career. Not many players can say that. Especially players who have been in the game as long as Pedroia has.

What Does the Future Hold For Pedroia?

“I’m at a point right now where I need some time.” – Dustin Pedroia.

Following the announcement that he is going to the 60 day injury list, the Red Sox held a press conference with Pedroia, Dave Dombrowski and Alex Cora. Pedroia, sporting a black shirt and a Red Sox cap, answered questions from the media. You can tell that he was fighting back emotions as questions were being asked. For a guy like Pedroia, who lives to compete, it’s tough to face reality.

With this leave of absence, maybe Pedroia will retire. It’s up to him and his family to determine what comes next. It hasn’t been an easy road for the 35 year old the past few seasons. For young fans, seeing a player who you’ve grown up watching every day retire, it’s a strange feeling. I only hope that when he does officially retire, the number 15 ends up in the right field rafters. Nobody should ever wear that number again.

Dustin Pedroia setback: Is his role in jeopardy?

The latest version of a Dustin Pedroia setback reawakens whispers stemming from last season. They are whispers that the most loyal Pedroia supporters have tried to silence for over a year. The whispers that might suggest Pedroia’s career winding down, due to the nagging issues from his surgically repaired knee.

Yet another setback makes a timeline for Pedroia’s return unclear

News out of the Red Sox camp today proved quite discouraging. After being scratched Dustin Pedroia setbackfrom a Saturday start in Portland due to knee soreness, Pedroia reportedly suffered a setback after a doctor examined him on Monday. The news is troubling, seeing as the second baseman has already spent a month on the injured list with a bad knee.

At the time of his IL placement, it was reported that this knee issue was not related to the part of his knee that has undergone multiple surgeries. In an at bat in Yankee Stadium, Pedroia “felt something pop,” which led to his eventual rehab assignments up in Maine. More recently, he missed Saturday’s game as more of a precaution, given some general soreness. Pedroia had been rehabbing for a decently long stretch of games. The fact that he has endured another setback ensures he will be out of the lineup for the foreseeable future.

If the latest issue really does differ from past knee injuries, then perhaps there is hope he can overcome it. As things currently stand, however, the signs point negative. Pedroia missed all but three games in 2018 due to that knee, and he fought through those limitations throughout 2017 as well. His former days as a masher and a dirt dog might well be a thing of the past. If he is to return in 2019, significant recovery will have to happen.

Pedroia will have competition for playing time once he returns

The self-proclaimed “Laser Show” has had a fantastic career in Boston, earning three World Series championships, an MVP, Rookie of the Year, four All-Star appearances, three Gold Gloves, and a reputation for laying it all on the line. There’s no doubt that his aggressive style of play has provided many victories. It could also be said that his hunger to play daily through injuries is what is hampering him. With that, the door is creaking open for that playing time to be absorbed.

Michael Chavis currently makes the loudest case to take the spot away, as the rookie infielder has thrown up a torrid .282/.407/.563 line in his first 20 big league games. His versatility to also play at third and first base gives him the edge.

Eduardo Nunez recently returned from the IL and ripped a two-run homer in his first game back. But the veteran has not been overly productive otherwise in 2019. Meanwhile, fan favorite utilityman Brock Holt recently suffered his own setback due to a bad shoulder. His recovery timeline is indefinite.

The Dustin Pedroia setback has been a major cog in the machine that has resumed the franchise’s place as a premiere team. It would be a shame for the knee that he’s had fixed so many times continue to hold him back. If he continues to miss time, there might not be a spot for him to come back to.

Red Sox Journal: Sox won 5 of 7 in the last week

A week ago today, the Sox defeated the Oakland A’s in the second of a three-game series at Fenway Park. Rick Porcello had his best outing of the season. He pitched 8 shutout innings and allowed just 2 hits and 2 walks. The Sox won the game, 5-1. A day later, on a rare Wednesday afternoon game, Boston was gunning for their first homesox won sweep of the season. Hector Velazquez started and pitched 2 innings of one-run ball. Marcus Walden, who has pitched exceptionally well after starting 2019 at Triple-A, pitched in relief and hurled 3 scoreless innings. Andrew Benintendi broke the game open in the sixth inning when he scored two runners on a bloop single to center field. Final score: Boston 7, Oakland 3. On Thursday, the team sent second baseman Dustin Pedroia on a rehab assignment to Double-A Portland. The veteran has since played in three games for the Sea Dogs. He has recorded 3 hits and 1 RBI. Also on Thursday, the Sox were in search for a season-high fourth straight victory. But, mistakes in the ninth inning by third baseman Rafael Devers and closer Ryan Brasier resulted in a White Sox win on a walk-off home run. Boston responded by winning the final three games of the series in impressive fashion. After the game 1 loss, they outscored Chicago 30-to-5. By the end of the weekend, the Red Sox had captured their third three-game winning streak of the season.

In-season Acquisitions

The team made several other transactions last week. On Friday, they added infielder Cody Asche to their 40-man roster. Pedrioa played in two games over the weekend in Double-A Portland.  Asche most recently played at the Triple-A level for the Sugar Land Skeeters of Sugar Land, Texas. His last major league appearance came in 2017 with the White Sox. On Saturday, Boston placed shortstop Tzu-Wei Lin on the 10-day Injured List (left knee sprain). The team recalled Eduardo Nunez from Pawtucket. Since being activated, Nunez has started two of three games. Also on Saturday, first baseman Joey Curletta was added to the 40-man roster after being claimed off waivers from Seattle. The 25-year-old has no major league experience, but was named the 2018 Texas League Player of the Year (Double-A) after posting 23 home runs and 94 RBI in 129 games. Curletta was assigned to the Paw Sox roster. Yesterday, before opening up a three-game series in Baltimore, the Red Sox placed starting pitcher David Price on the 10-day Injured List due to elbow tendinitis on his pitching arm. Price had been the team’s most consistent starting pitcher this season (1-2, 3.75 ERA, 1.14 WHIP). Right-handed pitcher Ryan Weber filled the roster spot after being called up. Weber pitched 4 scoreless innings last night in relief for starter Josh Smith. After losing last night in Baltimore 4-1, the Sox will send Hector Velazquez to the mound tonight. Chris Sale will pitch the series finale on Wednesday.